Asian Arts | Associations | Articles | Exhibitions | Galleries | Message Board



Message Board
Asian Art Forums

Message Listing by Date:
AsianArt.com Main Forum Message Index | Back | Post a New Message | Search | Private Mail | FAQ
Subject:Show to the experts:Song Guanyao Vase and Double-Ear Xi
Posted By: Chinese Song Guanyao Mon, Mar 16, 2009 IP: 219.142.66.242

They belongs to my family.







Subject:Show to the experts:Song Guanyao Vase and Double-Ear Xi
Posted By: pipane Tue, Mar 17, 2009

第一件【双耳瓶】器形是宋代官窑中的典型造型。但此件底胎的颜色不是宋代官窑的胎土,应该是现代的仿品。第二件【】胎土看起来与宋代的官窑很相近,但造型很怪异,不看实物不敢说新老否

From our expert (20 years expertise)
Regards,

Pipane

Subject:Re: Show to the experts:Song Guanyao Vase and Double-Ear Xi
Posted By: kk Thu, Mar 19, 2009

It looks like you are a professional photographer. with proper lightnings. Can you please post more clear detailed pictures of the mouth rim, clay body on the foot, inside, close up of the glaze etc...
How long they have been in your family and what size are they? Thanks. I will give my opinion when I see more info.

Subject:Re: Re: Show to the experts:Song Guanyao Vase and Double-Ear Xi
Posted By: David Sen Sun, Mar 22, 2009

I have sent more detailed pictures to you email, and looking forward to you more opinions. Thank you.

Subject:Re: Re: Re: Show to the experts:Song Guanyao Vase and Double-Ear Xi
Posted By: kk Tue, Mar 24, 2009

David
I received you pictures. The reason I am not answer your question immediately is I am waiting for your answers to my questions.

The first piece looks pretty good so it is either real or a recent year copies based on what I can see from your pictures. Song Guan ware are super rare and probably all are in major museums. I doubt you can find any piece on the open market today. If this is purchased by your family within the past thirty years, it is not a good sign. Even it is in your family for a very long time, you will still have hard time finding people to accepting it, because no one has the chance to handle them , except a couple museums. I will suggest you take it to the palace museum in Beijing or Taipei.

The second one is not correct. Are both pieces come from the same source?




Asian Arts | Associations | Articles | Exhibitions | Galleries | Message Board