Message
The key here is the signature and calligraphy, as it is EXACTLY the same, which is impossible without it being copied mechanically. It is simply impossible for any human being to sign their name and write something with exactly the same pattern, one work, one character, etc... maybe, not not an entire sequence. From what I can see in your images, the calligraphy and signature are the exact same, so I agree with the comments about one or the other having to be a copy, or both are a copy of a third. I am working on a Xu Beihong for a client right now... I examine the brush strokes of the subject matter, and the calligraphy and seals in detail in order to start to prove or disprove a case for authenticity. You would be welcome to contact me privately if you like. I am a credentialed appraiser through the International Society of Appraisers, I also consult on and broker art and antiques, and specialize in Asian art and antiques, antiquities, and fine western art. I wish I had better news for you, but I think you have received excellent replies from this group. The only way for me to know for sure is to examine Xu works in person in detail and often I even collaborate with my colleagues on pieces that may be very important to make sure of our conclusions. Who knows, maybe you have the original, and the other is a copy! It would be a nice find if that was the case. good luck, Greg.
|
Note that we are now reviewing postings before posting due to the large volume of SPAM and inappropriate postings on the forum. The validation process may take up to 12 hours. |
|